Terminal Dilapidations Schedule
A terminal (exit) schedule is served at or after lease expiry, claiming damages for all unremedied repairing, decorating, and reinstatement breaches. The RICS Dilapidations Protocol (2012) requires prompt service by the landlord; the tenant responds within 56 days with a Scott Schedule; both parties commission diminution in value reports; a without-prejudice surveyor meeting follows.
The Section 18(1) LTA 1927 Cap
Damages for dilapidations cannot exceed the diminution in the value of the reversion at lease end. The schedule face value almost always exceeds the actual diminution in value. Where the landlord intends to demolish or substantially alter (supercession — Salisbury v Gilmore [1942]), the diminution in value is nil and no damages are recoverable.
Jervis v Harris Clauses
Where the lease contains a Jervis v Harris self-help clause (Jervis v Harris [1996] Ch 195 CA), the landlord can enter, carry out the repairs, and recover the cost as a contractual debt — bypassing the s.18(1) cap. The landlord must actually carry out the works. The clause must be strictly complied with. Landlords should insist on Jervis v Harris clauses in all new commercial leases.
Reinstatement of Alterations
Where the lease requires reinstatement of tenant alterations, the landlord must specifically require reinstatement (in the licence to alter or by notice at or before lease expiry); failure to require reinstatement in time waives the right. Reinstatement costs can be very significant — payment in lieu is commonly negotiated. Ruxley Electronics v Forsyth [1996] AC 344 (HL) — courts will not order reinstatement where the cost is wholly disproportionate to the benefit.