Resulting Trusts, Constructive Trusts, and Express Declarations
Resulting trust: arises where A contributes to the purchase price of property taken in B's name — B holds on trust for A proportionately to the financial contribution; rebutted by evidence of gift intention; in commercial/investment property cases, resulting trust analysis applies (Laskar v Laskar [2008] CA); Stack v Dowden [2007] UKHL has largely displaced resulting trust in domestic cohabitation cases in favour of constructive trust analysis. Constructive trust: requires (i) common intention that the non-legal owner should have a beneficial share (expressed or inferred from financial contributions); and (ii) detrimental reliance on that intention (Lloyds Bank v Rosset [1991] HL); Stack v Dowden [2007] — for joint legal owners, starting point is joint beneficial ownership, displaced by evidence from the whole course of dealings; Jones v Kernott [2011] UKSC — court can impute a fair share where specific shares cannot be identified. Express declaration of trust (LPA 1925 s.53(1)(b)): must be in writing signed by the declarant; the most certain approach; a Deed of Trust should specify beneficial shares, income allocation, decision process, buy-out procedure, and sale procedure; basis for HMRC Form 17 (unequal rental income split for married couples/civil partners — submit within 60 days of declaration). Form A restriction at Land Registry: protects beneficial owners whose names are not on the title register; prevents registered proprietors from dealing without the beneficial owner's knowledge.
Overriding Interests and Conveyancing Due Diligence
Overriding interests (LRA 2002 Schedule 3 para 2): a beneficial interest held by a person in actual occupation of registered land overrides a registered disposition (sale or mortgage) — even if not registered at Land Registry; binds purchasers and mortgagees. Williams & Glyn's Bank v Boland [1981] HL: a wife's beneficial interest (financial contribution to purchase price; in actual occupation) overrode the bank's mortgage — transformed conveyancing practice. Due diligence: before exchange, enquire about all persons in actual occupation; inspect the property; obtain written confirmation from all adult occupiers that they claim no interest and will vacate on completion. Occupier consent forms: mortgage lenders require all adult occupiers to sign a consent/waiver form before advancing funds — acknowledging the mortgage and confirming they will not assert an overriding interest. TOLATA 1996 s.14: where co-owners (trustees/beneficiaries) cannot agree on the management or sale of property held on trust, either party can apply to the court for an order for sale, partition, or other relief; the court considers all the circumstances including the purposes of the trust and the welfare of any beneficiary who is a minor. SDLT: transfers of beneficial interests by trust deed (creating or varying a beneficial share) may be chargeable transactions for SDLT where consideration passes; gratuitous declarations are generally exempt but specialist advice required.