Market Value in the No Scheme World — Disturbance, Injurious Affection and Severance
The primary head of CPO compensation is the open market value of the interest acquired, assessed in the 'no scheme world' — ignoring both the enhancement in value caused by the acquiring scheme and the blight (reduction in value) caused by its announcement. Both the claimant and the acquiring authority appoint independent RICS-qualified valuers; if compensation cannot be agreed, the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) determines the value.
- Market value (LCA 1961 s.5 Rule 2): open market value of the freehold or leasehold interest at the valuation date (date of entry or General Vesting Declaration — whichever is later)
- 'No scheme world' (LCA 1961 s.5 Rule 3; Neighbourhood Planning Act 2017): assessed ignoring both the enhancement and the blight caused by the scheme — can produce a value significantly different from current market price
- RICS valuation: the claimant should appoint their own independent RICS-qualified Red Book valuer — professional fees for the valuer and solicitor are recoverable from the acquiring authority
- Disturbance compensation (LCA 1961 s.7 and case law — 'consequential losses'): removal costs; relocation costs; cost of finding and fitting out alternative premises; rental income lost during the dispossession period; temporary accommodation costs; professional fees for relocation
- Injurious affection and severance (LCA 1961 s.7 — PARTIAL ACQUISITIONS ONLY): where only part of the landlord's land is acquired, the depreciation in value of the retained land is also compensable — severance (physical separation) and injurious affection (diminution in value of retained land caused by the scheme works)
Home Loss Payment, Basic Loss Payment and Advance Payment
Beyond market value and disturbance, two statutory top-up payments are available depending on whether the landlord occupies the property as their main home (home loss payment) or owns it as an investment (basic loss payment). Both must be actively claimed by written notice to the acquiring authority.
- Home loss payment (LCA 1973 s.29): available to owners AND qualifying tenants displaced from their MAIN DWELLING; must have occupied as main residence for 12+ months immediately before displacement; amount: 10% of market value; minimum £7,800; maximum £78,000 (2023/24 — reviewed annually by DLUHC); write to the acquiring authority to claim
- Basic loss payment (LCA 1973 s.33A-33C — added by PCPA 2004): available where the claimant does NOT qualify for home loss payment (e.g., investment landlords who let rather than occupy); 7.5% of the market value of the acquired interest; no minimum; maximum £75,000 (2023/24 — reviewed annually); the claimant must have held a qualifying interest for at least 1 year before the notice to treat or General Vesting Declaration
- Advance payment obligation (LCA 1961 s.52 as amended): the acquiring authority MUST pay 90% of the agreed or estimated compensation within 2 months of the claimant's written request — always make a written advance payment request immediately after entry
- Interest on late advance payment: if the advance payment is not made within 2 months, interest accrues at the statutory interest rate from the date of the request (or the date of entry if earlier)
- LURA 2023 reforms: the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023 has strengthened the 'no scheme world' provisions and is introducing measures to speed up the CPO process — being implemented in phases from 2024
Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) — Dispute Resolution, Calderbank Offers and Costs
Where the acquiring authority and the claimant cannot agree on the amount of compensation, either party may refer the dispute to the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) (UTLC) — successor to the former Lands Tribunal. The UTLC has specialist surveyor-members and lawyer-members experienced in compulsory purchase valuation disputes.
- UTLC procedure: each party files a statement of case; exchange of expert RICS valuation reports; hearing before a Tribunal Member (surveyor-member or lawyer-member); written decision
- Costs generally follow the event: the losing party typically pays the winning party's reasonable costs — subject to the UTLC's discretion
- Calderbank (sealed) offer: a sealed offer of settlement made by one party — if the claimant's award exceeds the authority's sealed offer, the claimant typically recovers costs from the date of the offer; if the award is at or below the offer, the authority may recover its costs from that date. Making a well-judged Calderbank offer is an important tactical step
- Appeal: UTLC decisions are subject to appeal only on a point of law (to the Court of Appeal) — factual findings on value are rarely disturbed on appeal