Service Occupancy vs Tenancy
Key test (Norris v Checksfield [1991] 1 WLR 1241): genuine necessity for proper performance of duties = service occupancy (licence); mere convenience or incidentality = tenancy. Genuine necessity examples: 24-hour caretaker; resident warden; hotel housekeeper on 24h call; estate manager required on site. Less clear: farm worker who could commute; security guard with fixed hours. Exclusive possession does not determine the issue — service occupancy can arise even with exclusive possession where necessity is established. Consequence: licensee has no HA 1988 security of tenure; right to occupy ends with employment.
Assured Agricultural Occupancies
Housing Act 1988 Sch 3: assured agricultural occupancy (AAO) arises where (1) licensee or tenant; (2) qualifying agricultural worker; (3) only or principal home. AAO has same security of tenure as assured tenancy — employer-landlord needs court order for possession; HA 1988 grounds must be established. Case 1 (Sch 3): alternative accommodation available. Ground 16 (HA 1988): former employee (discretionary ground — not mandatory). Rent Act (Agriculture) Act 1976: pre-1989 agricultural workers; Rent Act 1976 protection may still apply.
Recovering Possession from Service Occupant
Service occupancy ends automatically with employment — no notice to quit required (no tenancy). Employer demands vacant possession; if refused, issues county court possession proceedings. No HA 1988 ground needed — occupant has no statutory security. Disputed arrangements: if occupant argues tenancy (not licence), court determines nature — keep clear contemporaneous documentation establishing service occupancy character. Employment contract: record in writing that accommodation is service occupancy; employee is licensee not tenant; right to occupy ends with employment.
HMRC Benefits in Kind
ITEPA 2003 ss.97-113: living accommodation provided by reason of employment is taxable benefit in kind — annual value (broadly market rental value). Exemption (necessary for duties): accommodation genuinely necessary for proper performance of employee's duties — no benefit in kind charge. Exemption (customary provision): customarily provided for type of employee; required for better performance. Where exemption does not apply: employee declares on self-assessment; employer reports P11D; employer Class 1A NIC applies.
Scotland and Northern Ireland
Scotland: Private Housing (Tenancies) (Scotland) Act 2016 (PRT) excludes service occupancies where accommodation is necessary for performance of duties. Scottish agricultural workers: Agricultural Holdings (Scotland) Act 2003; Scottish Land Court jurisdiction. Northern Ireland: Private Tenancies (NI) Order 2006; service occupancies excluded from statutory tenancy regime; separate agricultural worker protections. Employment law overlap: notice periods; redundancy; unfair dismissal — employment law must be considered alongside possession when recovering service accommodation. Always take specialist legal advice.