How Turnover Rent Works
Base rent: fixed minimum (~70-80% of open market rent) payable regardless of trading. Turnover top-up: (Gross Turnover × Rate) minus Base Rent (where positive); commonly 6-12% for retail. Natural break: turnover level where tenant begins paying more than base rent (= Base Rent ÷ Rate). Quarterly base rent payments in advance (RICS standard); annual certified turnover statement from tenant; year-end reconciliation. Example: base rent £200,000; rate 10%; natural break £2m; gross turnover £2.5m; top-up = 10% × £500,000 = £50,000; total rent £250,000.
Gross Turnover Definition
Inclusions (typical): all sales at/from premises; gift card redemptions; online sales attributable to the store (click and collect; geographic attribution). Exclusions (typical): VAT; customer refunds; staff discounts; credit card processing fees; concession sales (unless commission received). Online/omnichannel: attribution of digital sales to physical stores increasingly important as omnichannel retail grows — define clearly to avoid disputes. Concessions: exclude concessionaire turnover unless tenant receives commission/licence fee (which is included).
Audit Rights and Obligations
Quarterly estimates: tenant provides estimated quarterly turnover for base rent calculation. Annual certified accounts: delivered within 3-4 months of accounting year end. Landlord audit rights: inspect trading records, EPOS data, financial accounts — essential to verify reported turnover. Under-reporting consequences: additional rent; audit costs; interest; potentially forfeiture in serious cases. EPOS data: modern leases may include real-time or monthly EPOS data-sharing — simplifies reconciliation and reduces under-reporting risk.
COVID-19 and Turnover Rent
Commerz Real v TFS Stores [2021] EWHC 863 (Ch): retailer Pandora sought to withhold rent during COVID lockdowns (frustration; force majeure; implied term). High Court rejected — fixed rent remained payable. Turnover rent leases: zero trading during lockdowns → zero turnover top-up; base rent reduced effective burden. Pandemic accelerated: shorter leases; break clauses; hybrid turnover/fixed rent structures. Post-pandemic: major shopping centre landlords (Hammerson, British Land) increased proportion of retail portfolio on turnover or hybrid arrangements.
Rent Review and Scotland
Base rent review: open market value review or RPI/CPI indexation; upward-only in prime retail. Review impact on natural break: higher base rent raises natural break — tenant needs higher turnover before paying top-up. Assignment: outgoing tenant must comply with reporting obligations for year of assignment; incoming tenant takes on obligations from completion. Keep-open covenants/minimum turnover: some landlords require minimum trading performance and minimum turnover thresholds. Scotland: turnover rent used in Scottish retail (Glasgow/Edinburgh/Aberdeen shopping centres); Scots law governs; same reporting and audit structure in practice.