Security of tenure, incontestable Notice to Quit cases and contestable NtQ (ALT consent)
AHA 1986 tenants have strong statutory security of tenure — the landlord must serve a 12-month NtQ, and most NtQs can be contested by the tenant.
- Valid NtQ (s.25 AHA 1986): written; at least 12 months' notice; effective at end of a tenancy year (anniversary date)
- Incontestable Cases (Sch 3 Part I): Case B (planning permission — non-agricultural use required); Case D (failure to comply with Remediation Notice — at least 6 months for non-monetary breach; 2 months for monetary breach); Case E (irreparable breach — incapable of remedy); Case F (insolvency/bankruptcy); Case G (death — NtQ within 3 months of landlord notification by personal representatives)
- Contestable NtQ: tenant serves Counter-Notice within 1 month → ALT must consent for NtQ to take effect; ALT grants consent only if fair and reasonable landlord test satisfied (s.26(2) — relative hardship; landlord's need for land; tenant's agricultural livelihood dependence)
Succession rights (Part IV — two generations), suitability test, retirement succession and arbitration rent reviews
Succession rights are the most significant protection for AHA 1986 tenants — up to two generations can succeed, dramatically extending the period during which the landlord cannot recover the land.
- Succession on death or retirement: eligible close relative (spouse; civil partner; child; sibling; parent) — substantially employed on holding 5 of last 7 years; principal livelihood test — must apply to ALT for new tenancy direction
- Suitability test (Sch 6 para 7-8): ALT assesses training; practical experience; financial resources; landlord's reasonable expectations — unsuitable nominees can be refused
- Maximum two successions: original tenant → first successor; first successor → second successor — no third succession; landlord can recover possession after second successor dies or retires
- Retirement succession (s.49): retiring tenant nominates eligible close relative; same eligibility and suitability criteria apply
- Arbitration rent reviews (s.12): either party may demand — not more than once every 3 years; open market rent (3-year yearly tenancy basis); must disregard tenant's improvements; grant-aided improvements; and scarcity element